Advertisement
I am really embarrassed by some of the things I have heard white liberals saying about Barack Obama. Some of the things I have heard:
"He's not actually black, because he's half-white".
"Michael Jordan is black. Obama is black-ish."
"I wish people would stop talking about the factor of race in Obama's success. Can't we just move on?"
"Obama could be an Uncle Sam, or he could be an Uncle Tom"
Why do white liberals continue to talk about the black identity and experience as if they are authorities on it? It's really embarrassing that so many white "liberals" and "revolutionaries" refuse to critically examine our own privilege and role in the white supremacist power structure. White liberals cannot speak as if we know the experience of growing up with brown skin in this country. Racial identity is a social construct anyways, "black" isn't a kind of DNA or blood type. But it IS a very tangible social identity that is used by our society to describe brown-skinned people of African descent. This identity has been used to enslave and systematically disenfranchise people with brown skin since the inception of our society.
With this identity and the history associated with it, why do white liberals think we have the right to validate it or say whether or not someone is "black"???? It is really embarrassing to hear so-called "liberals" let alone "revolutionary" people flaunting their own white privilege to talk about whether or not someone is black enough or a sell-out to the black community.
WAKE UP! If you really want to change racial inequality, stop acting like you are an authority on black culture! Step back and listen to what the black community is actually saying- you don't have to agree or disagree.
We just elected a black president in a society where virtually nobody thought this was possible only decades ago. The factor of race in this election is NOT to be ignored, avoided, or marginalized. It SHOULD be talked about, and that dialog should be OPEN without fear. We, as "white liberals", have the privilege to choose to be 'colorblind', however, our society is NOT colorblind, and nothing we do is going to change the realities that people of different skin colors face on the streets, and in the workplaces and homes of America.
Let's take this incredible time in our society to keep a dialog open and continue to challenge our own roles for the greater good.
If I've struck a chord, good!
Comments welcome.
ryan
"He's not actually black, because he's half-white".
"Michael Jordan is black. Obama is black-ish."
"I wish people would stop talking about the factor of race in Obama's success. Can't we just move on?"
"Obama could be an Uncle Sam, or he could be an Uncle Tom"
Why do white liberals continue to talk about the black identity and experience as if they are authorities on it? It's really embarrassing that so many white "liberals" and "revolutionaries" refuse to critically examine our own privilege and role in the white supremacist power structure. White liberals cannot speak as if we know the experience of growing up with brown skin in this country. Racial identity is a social construct anyways, "black" isn't a kind of DNA or blood type. But it IS a very tangible social identity that is used by our society to describe brown-skinned people of African descent. This identity has been used to enslave and systematically disenfranchise people with brown skin since the inception of our society.
With this identity and the history associated with it, why do white liberals think we have the right to validate it or say whether or not someone is "black"???? It is really embarrassing to hear so-called "liberals" let alone "revolutionary" people flaunting their own white privilege to talk about whether or not someone is black enough or a sell-out to the black community.
WAKE UP! If you really want to change racial inequality, stop acting like you are an authority on black culture! Step back and listen to what the black community is actually saying- you don't have to agree or disagree.
We just elected a black president in a society where virtually nobody thought this was possible only decades ago. The factor of race in this election is NOT to be ignored, avoided, or marginalized. It SHOULD be talked about, and that dialog should be OPEN without fear. We, as "white liberals", have the privilege to choose to be 'colorblind', however, our society is NOT colorblind, and nothing we do is going to change the realities that people of different skin colors face on the streets, and in the workplaces and homes of America.
Let's take this incredible time in our society to keep a dialog open and continue to challenge our own roles for the greater good.
If I've struck a chord, good!
Comments welcome.
ryan
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: Obama and White Privilege in My Community
Thu, November 6, 2008 - 5:35 PM"He's not actually black, because he's half-white"
this one actually rings true, but whoever said it probably isn't aware of rampant racism within the african-american community.... it was maddening to see white pundits discuss whether or not obama was "black enough" to win the black vote especially since i never saw any of them go and as the african-american community if that was a concern... though i'm sure it wasn't an issue for most african-americans (there aren't that many in my peer group for me to ask) i remember what it's like being labeled, for many reasons, an oreo....
and really, the idea that obama might sell out the african-american community being anyone's concern at this point is hilarious. other than generally being part of the lower class disenfranchised oppressed portion of our society that comprises most non-white people and a lot of white people african-americans have not been singled out for special reparations in a long time... it hasn't really been an issue since the push for repealing affirmative action measures a few years back....
don't feel so bad though. people will always speak with auhority concerning the experience of others. not much you can do about that unless you want to call them on it, and perhaps teach them a thing or two.
-
Re: Obama and White Privilege in My Community
Fri, November 7, 2008 - 6:15 PM"I wish people would stop talking about the factor of race in Obama's success. Can't we just move on?"
In a certain context, I agree.... obama isn't stating his sucess was factored by his race so why should anyone else? he was the better candidate, regardless of his skin color...
i'm looking forward to the day where such statment would be as significant as "his facial hair was a big factor is his success"
-
-
Re: Obama and White Privilege in My Community
Fri, November 7, 2008 - 6:23 PMps. i think mccain said it very well, speaking of obama's victory. It truly is a monumnetal event in history and shoud be recognized and celebrated... i fully agree - i'm very proud of america.... we should talk about it often - having a black presidnet - it's awesome
but if mccain had said " barack only beat me because he was black", i would not have been thrilled....
-
> i'm looking forward to the day <
Sat, November 8, 2008 - 8:36 AMi get what you're saying with this, that you're ready for the racial issues and divisions in the country to be healed. me too. but i don't think race will ever go away, as a factor in how people see each other, simply at a biological level. and it's important not to pretend that the day has arrived, that mythical day when race is not a factor. race is a factor in everything. each of us exists in a social context that our race helps define. i am looking forward to the day when everyone feels that reality. once we can admit that no one is colorblind, we can try to work on building a society that's fair despite our differences.
-
-
Re: Obama and White Privilege in My Community
Sat, November 8, 2008 - 9:25 PMIf you're talking to someone who calls themself "a liberal" or "a conservative" or "a revolutionary" you're not exactly about to have a nuanced political discussion. -
-
Re: Obama and White Privilege in My Community
Fri, December 12, 2008 - 3:34 PMThanks to everybody for your insightful responses. Between here and other forums I have gotten a lot of discussion going with people and it has really opened my mind to peoples' perspectives. My goal here is to learn and this has happened.
The only thing here I wanted to specifically reply to is Benchun, your comment. I agree wholeheartedly. I was actually trying to say exactly what you said, but you weren't the only one who interpreted it as the opposite :( I guess I need to work on my english skills! Essentially my underlying point was, as you said, it's "important not to pretend that the day has arrived, that mythical day when race is not a factor". When I said some people have the privilege to be "colorblind", what I meant was they have the option of ignoring the role of race in every day life, whereas some people don't.
Also a few people have commented on my use of the word black vs. african american... thanks for bringing all this to the surface!
Thanks all,
ryan
-